Thursday, 13 October 2016

Reader Response 3rd draft: The concrete advantage

In the article “The Concrete Advantage”, National Ready Mixed Concrete Association states that the installation of waterproof concrete will simplify the design, building and maintenance processes. The article also discusses about the advantages of using waterproof concretes and how various stakeholders will benefit from using it.
The article claims that the unique characteristics of the waterproof concrete make it commercially viable, and mentions that the permanent built in waterproofing makes it less prone to wear and tear, and allows for easier identification and reconditioning of the minor defects. In addition, the article explains how the defects can be rectified with polyurethane grout injection repair, and it can be done without disrupting the green roof. Hence the article evaluates that it will shorten the drafting process, lower the per square foot costing as membranes are omitted and there will be a reduction in the overall construction cost.
Constructions should utilize waterproof concrete as its unique characteristics make it commercially viable as it simplifies construction processes and makes maintenance easier.

The first reason is the omission of the waterproofing membrane. “Case study of Miami Science Museum Aquarium” (n.d.) observes that the addition of a special mixture into concrete mix enhances waterproofing in adverse conditions, even without the application of waterproofing membrane. “Hycrete Benefits” (n.d.) estimates that this approach reduces the construction cost by 30% as the design phase was shortened due to the omission of the costly membranes. This supports the commercial viability of using waterproofing concretes in greenroofs as compared to the application of waterproofing membrane.

Furthermore, National Ready Mixed Concrete Association explains about the complications of repair work relating to traditional waterproofing method. In a supporting article written by Kadlubowski (2014), the common problem of waterproofing layers is the damage of the fragile layers due to rough handling during constructions. Kadlubowski (2014) also mentions that the grade of waterproofing layer is essential as it is very difficult to carry out maintenance work thereafter. In addition, National Ready Mixed Concrete Association suggests that with the use of waterproofing concrete, there will not be a need to wait for the concrete to cure before applying the membrane, taking away precious time of the construction. This reduces the overall construction cost, as time equal cost and a longer construction period will elevate the cost on site due to rental of construction machines and manpower.

In addition, National Ready Mixed Concrete Association claims that with the use of waterproofing concrete the use of root barrier for the greenroofs can be excluded. In a research study by Tan, Chew and Wong (2012), they share that plants with growing roots tend to penetrate the waterproofing layer causing severe damage to the membranes. Tan, Chew and Wong (2012) warn that tremendous amount of effort and money are needed to carry out the tedious repair works and explain that the process will kill the green plants as the top layers have to be removed to reapply the membrane. National Ready Mixed Concrete Association states that minor cracks from the penetrating roots can be easily identified and resolved with a grout injection repair that is cost efficient. The unique characteristic simplifies the maintenance work needed for waterproofing concrete and it reduces the future maintenance cost.

In conclusion, National Ready Mixed Concrete Association discusses valid points, and is able to justify the advantages of using waterproofing concretes. The supporting articles further highlight the strength and characteristics of the waterproof concretes, showing the commercial and technical viability of using such concrete. Hence, the use of waterproofing concrete will benefit various stakeholders of the construction process.






References:

The Concrete Advantage. (n.d). Retrieved from http://www.greenrooftops.org/advantage.html

Case study of Miami Science Museum Aquarium. (n.d). Retrieved from http://www.hycrete.com/wp-content/uploads/Hycrete-Case-Study-Miami-Science-Museum_v9-8-17-16.pdf

Hycrete Benefits. (n.d). Retrieved from

Richard P. Kadlubowski (2014, November 26). An Overview Of Waterproofing Solutions. Retrieved from

K.K.Tan, M.Y.L.Chew and N.H.Wong (2012, May 9). Effects of plant roots on waterproofing membrane. Retrieved from http://www.bse.polyu.edu.hk/researchCentre/Fire_Engineering/summary_of_output/journal/IJAS/V8/p76-88.pdf




No comments:

Post a Comment